News: Campaigners say Universal Credit is letting young people down

Researchers say improvements to Universal Credit are urgently needed to help support young adults in Scotland.

The Poverty Alliance spoke with young adult parents and care-experienced young adults about their experiences of claiming Universal Credit.

The research highlighted how the application and process can be confusing and hard to navigate for young adults, and how interactions with work coaches are inconsistent.

Positive examples of support were reported by some young adults, but others recalled difficult, and even hostile, encounters with work coaches and Jobcentre staff – including being ‘watched’ over as they typed job applications, or being asked intrusive and inappropriate questions during their Universal Credit interview.

Everyone who claims Universal Credit is assigned a Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) work coach. Based in Jobcentres, the role of work coaches involves helping people to claim benefits and to prepare for, find, and stay in work.

However, this research highlights concerning evidence of young adults feeling ‘judged’ by their work coaches. One said: “Some [work coaches] can be really rude and quite horrible to you about things, or the way they speak to you about things. Especially because I’m quite young.”

Young parents also expressed frustration at being asked to come to the Jobcentre for appointments that could easily be conducted over the phone. They said this showed a lack of respect for their time, and a lack of understanding about their roles and responsibilities as mothers and caregivers.

One young adult parent said: “I go to the job centre for five minutes, then I have to leave and go back. They could phone me and say, ‘You still working? You still doing your work search?’… I don’t feel I have to be there, face to face every single two weeks when I’m a carer for my mum.”

Like other groups claiming Universal Credit, young people must wait five weeks before they get their first payment. The research highlighted the hardship this can cause.

One care-experienced young adult said: “It took me about seven to eight weeks just to be able to be put on Universal Credit, then I had to wait the additional five. For… that amount of time, I had no money, no support… I had to rely on my college lunch as my one meal of the day at that point.”

A key issue with the current UC system is that those under the age of 25 receive a lower standard allowance – £86.32 less each month – than people aged 25 and over.

Young parents reported worries about affording basic groceries, as well as providing clothes and shoes for growing children. One said their payment ‘doesn’t touch’ what is needed to pay for children’s clubs and other activities.

Poverty Alliance senior research officer Dr Lauren Wilks said: “A just social security system provides people with enough income to meet their household needs and gives them stable and reliable support to build for the future. But the young adults we talked with told us how they struggled to access information and support and how the lower payment amount left them struggling to get by. It doesn’t have to be like this, and the DWP and UK Government can make improvements to address these issues.”

Among a number of recommendations, the report urges the UK Government to:

  • Improve the quality of support offered to young adults through poverty awareness, care-experience awareness, and trauma-informed practice training for work coaches.
  • End the arbitrary five-week wait for Universal Credit to ensure that no young adult is left without adequate income.
  • Remove age discrimination in Universal Credit payments so that there is a single standard allowance.
  • Ensure that social security payments rise each year, either by inflation or earnings growth, whichever is higher.
  • Ensure sanctioning young people is exceptional rather than the rule and ends the use of sanctions for people with complex needs.

Poverty Alliance chief executive Peter Kelly said: ““The social security system should be run to provide support, not to be an obstacle in people’s efforts to live a decent life. We will be sharing this important research with Scotland’s MPs and asking for their help to build a Universal Credit system that meets the needs of young people and their families, understands the particular difficulties they face, and doesn’t punish them with unjust and arbitrary sanctions.

“We will also be reminding them of the important Essentials Guarantee campaign by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Trussell Trust – to make sure Universal Credit covers daily essentials for everyone.”

You can view the report in the window below, or download it from here.

Stay in the loop