Annie McCcrmack, Taking Action on Rural Development OfficerThe Poverty Alliance
We recently hoped to have the opportunity to speak at a Special Full Council meeting of Aberdeenshire Council on the decision to mothball four rural nurseries in the county. In the end we didn't get to speak, as the council decided to put the plans on hold.
Over the past year in the work I have been doing on Taking Action on Rural Poverty, I have seen values shared across Aberdeenshire: fairness, dignity, opportunity, and a commitment to strong, thriving communities.
These nursery mothballings , while perhaps intended as a cost-saving measure, stand in direct conflict with those values. They risk making life harder for the very families who already face the greatest barriers — families doing their best to stay afloat in the face of rising living costs, limited local opportunities, and the added costs of rural life.
They go directly against the commitments Aberdeenshire Council has made to tackling poverty and supporting rural communities.
There is a perception, even within Aberdeenshire, that it is an affluent area, but the deprivation data does not accurately reflect challenges faced by people across the region. Accessing essential services, including vital medical appointments, can force a reliance on private car ownership. Aberdeenshire’s transport infrastructure is a barrier rather than a support to people on low incomes to move around and access employment, education, training and opportunities. Some 15% of children in Aberdeenshire live in poverty.
We’ve heard directly from people living on low incomes about the “rural poverty premium”—the unavoidable extra costs of living rurally. It’s a double hit that most acutely affects lone parents, disabled people, carers, and women. Closing nurseries would compound these pressures.
Access to local, free or affordable childcare is not a luxury—it is a matter of equity. It gives children the best start in life. It gives parents—especially mothers—the opportunity to work, to train, and to support their families with dignity. And it helps communities remain vibrant and economically viable.
Taking that access away means higher travel costs for families who can least afford it, reduced working hours or job loss for parents, and ultimately, a greater risk of poverty for those already living close to the edge.
This is not an abstract issue. It is about real families, in real communities, trying to build better lives—and about whether or not public services are there to support them. Free and affordable childcare is recognised as a lever that can be used to tackle, and prevent poverty, but also needs to be accessible in rural areas for it to be effective.
Let’s be honest: this decision would have hit women hardest. They’re more likely to bear the responsibility of childcare, more likely to reduce work hours, and more likely to fall deeper into poverty as a result. That undermines not only family wellbeing but the economic resilience of whole communities—and it goes against the objectives set out in Aberdeenshire’s own Local Child Poverty Action Plan.
We’re not speaking alone. Fourteen organisations, including One Parent Families Scotland, Scottish Womens Budget Group and Engender have joined us, along with our panel of people with lived experience. Together, we urged the Council to reconsider this course of action.
This is not just a social issue—it’s an economic one. Accessible early years education enables parents, particularly mothers, to work and earn. It supports economic growth, strengthens communities, and helps address demographic challenges that rural areas like Aberdeenshire faces. Equity in accessing free childcare can be a way to tackle the attainment gap: the gap between children from low-income and high-income households starts early. By age 5, it is 10–13 months. Joseph Rowntree Foundation esearch suggests that high quality early childhood education and care can have positive and long-lasting impacts on children’s outcomes, particularly for disadvantaged children.
In 2024, Aberdeenshire Council’s own commissioned research highlighted that quality childcare helps parents access training, employment, and improves mental health.
A recent survey by the Scottish Women’s Budget Group showed that Aberdeenshire’s current childcare offer is already falling short. More than half of respondents said the lack of affordable, accessible childcare was affecting their ability to work. A significant number are considering leaving the region altogether.
We welcome that the council has paused the mothballing of these settings, and are committing to consult meaningfully with affected communities, and hope they commit to assessing fully the long-term impact of any decisions—with a focus on the Council’s statutory obligations to reduce child poverty.
Nursery provision is not a luxury. It is core infrastructure that allows families and communities to thrive. By eroding that infrastructure, local authorities fail to meet their own targets and the people they represent.
Enter your email address to receive regular e-updates about our work. If at any time you want to stop receiving these, simply contact us. We’ll keep your details safe and won’t share them with any other organisations for their marketing purposes. For full details see our Privacy Policy.