This report is the first of a series capturing our learning around the processes of engagement and bringing people who have experienced the unjust cost of rural living into the centre of the work. In this report, we reflect on the decision-making process we used to allocate seed funding to two test of change pilot projects.
You can read the report in the window above,download it in PDF format from here, or read a more accessible summary below.
Taking Action on Rural Poverty
Learning from a participatory approach to the Test of Change decision‑making process
Introduction
Learning about what works—and what does not—when taking a participatory approach to tackling the rural poverty premium is a key aim of the Taking Action on Rural Poverty (TARP) project at The Poverty Alliance.
The project invested £60,000 of seed funding in two Test of Change pilots. Alongside reaching funding decisions, the project team reflected on what was learned from involving people with lived experience, local organisations, and national stakeholders in the decision‑making process.
- Can a participatory decision‑making process work?
- What is the value of involving people with lived experience?
Can a participatory decision‑making process work?
Yes—participatory decision‑making can work when it is:
- Well‑paced, with enough time for meaningful involvement
- Clear in purpose and scope, so participants understand their role
- Flexible and adaptive, while still applying rigour and integrity
Key learning included the importance of being mindful of how much is asked of people with lived experience, framing complex ideas such as “systems change” in tangible ways, and drawing on private‑sector expertise where useful to address complex cost‑of‑living systems.
Is it helpful to involve people with lived experience?
Yes—involving people with lived experience was valuable for both participants and the project team.
Benefits for participants
- Participation felt empowering
- People felt less isolated in their experiences of rural poverty
- Greater understanding of shared challenges across rural Scotland
Benefits for the project
- Challenged assumptions
- Generated practical and insightful questions
- Strengthened internal debate
- Shaped the scope and design of the pilots
About the Test of Change pilots
Project objectives
- Reduce the rural poverty premium (the higher cost of living in rural areas)
- Build on the strengths of rural communities
- Test practical solutions that can inform wider policy and systems change
Two pilots were selected—one in Aberdeenshire and one in Argyll and Bute. Both must be delivered and evaluated before September 2026.
Selection criteria for pilots
- One fundable project in each local authority area
- Combined budget of £60,000
- Clear impact on the rural cost of living
- Alignment with Citizens’ Panel priority issues:
- Fuel poverty
- Transport barriers and access to healthcare
- Food insecurity
- Housing
- Childcare
- Feasibility within timescales and budget
The role of the TARP Citizens’ Panels
Panel composition
- 12–13 members per panel
- People with direct experience of living rurally on low incomes
- Monthly online meetings
- Inclusion of island residents in Argyll and Bute
Panel contributions
- Identifying priority issues
- Contributing to decision‑making criteria
- Providing feedback on shortlisted proposals
- Offering ongoing oversight during implementation
Wider stakeholder engagement
Over 280 stakeholders were consulted through national and local online events, sector‑specific meetings, and one‑to‑one discussions. This led to 50 potential project ideas, 11 shortlisted proposals, and 2 pilots selected for funding.
Selected Test of Change pilots
Argyll and Bute: ALIenergy partnership
This pilot supports people on low incomes to benefit from renewable energy by:
- Improving access to information on retrofit and green energy
- Supporting social tenants with heat pumps or solar panels
- Ensuring households are on suitable energy tariffs
- Helping people use low‑carbon heating systems effectively
Aberdeenshire: Grampian Credit Union partnership
This pilot addresses the high cost of off‑grid heating oil by:
- Providing interest‑free loans for heating‑oil refills
- Helping households spread costs
- Enabling people to shop around for cheaper suppliers
Key learning from the participatory approach
1. Involving lived experience is invaluable
Lived experience participation strengthened decision‑making by improving relevance and realism, raising unexpected but important questions, and shaping pilot design and implementation. Participants described the process as empowering and confidence‑building.
2. There are no simple solutions to rural poverty
The rural poverty premium is caused by interconnected systems. Identifying problems was easier than designing solutions; ongoing involvement was more effective than one‑off consultation; and external speakers helped make potential solutions more tangible.
3. Balance involvement without overburdening people
Some stages were demanding—such as applying complex decision criteria and making difficult trade‑offs. The team adapted by asking for general feedback instead of formal scoring and allowing different levels of involvement at different stages.
4. Expertise is needed to address complex systems
Because of technical and structural complexity, external expertise was essential. Private‑sector input strengthened proposals, and clear communication with realistic expectations was critical.
5. Clearly define the system you want to change
The term “systems change” can be unclear. Focusing on specific, tangible outcomes can improve engagement and help participants understand expected impact.
Future considerations
The decision‑making process generated learning that will inform future advocacy and campaigning, new pilot development, and ongoing partnerships beyond this project. Some proposals not funded through TARP are being explored through alternative funding routes.
Enter your email address to receive regular e-updates about our work. If at any time you want to stop receiving these, simply contact us. We’ll keep your details safe and won’t share them with any other organisations for their marketing purposes. For full details see our Privacy Policy.